Specify an unfamiliar outcome
Take an outcome signal you have not seen and produce a ratifiable specification, without the stage worksheets.
Independent specification record
The complete path from signal to ratifiable spec
The spec was written without the worksheets and survived ratification.
Sibling repository../payments-validation-fixture836a75dShared with course 301. You work from specs/product/payments.md rather than the diff.
Why this stage exists
Transfer is demonstrated when the prompts are removed.
This stage needs a facilitator-supplied signal. Round 0 cannot be reused, because you have now read its answer.
What you start from
Work from these inputs only. Anything not on this list is either a later stage’s concern or a decision you do not own.
- Unfamiliar signal
- A facilitator-supplied outcome signal with hidden intent.
- The workbench
- The full reference, with no prescribed subset.
- A ratifier
- Someone who has not seen your working.
The complete path from signal to ratifiable spec
One worked pass, so the shape of the work is visible before you do it on your own.
- Diagnose what the signal does not decide.
- Write the hypothesis, then the criteria with their evaluation paths.
- Bound the scope and decompose.
- Submit for ratification and record the result.
What this turns onThe assessment measures whether a pod could take your spec and return what was intended.
Do the work
- Work alone from the unfamiliar signal.
- Produce the specification.
- Submit it cold for ratification.
- Compare it with the hidden intent after submission.
You produce
Independent specification record
- Outcome hypothesis
- Acceptance contract
- Scope boundary
- Decomposition
- Ratification result
- Bounded acceptance claim
Challenge your own result
The signal looks clear and nothing seems ambiguous. What do you write?
Show how this resolves
Write the exclusions and the evaluation paths anyway. A signal that looks unambiguous usually has an unstated policy behind it, and the fastest way to find it is to try writing the criterion that would settle it.
Ready to continue when
- The spec was written without the stage worksheets.
- It survived ratification, or its objections are owned.
- The acceptance claim is bounded by evidence that could exist.
What transfersDiagnose, hypothesize, specify, bound, decompose and ratify without course prompts.
Source · 02 Accountability assignment